If your a Colt’s fan what would you do with Payton Manning and the 1st pick in the draft? First of all my Colts fans you should be upset because the GM set your team up for failure. The defense was improved, and he know good and well that everyone knows that Painter was not a good back-up, but never did anything about it. But I would trade the pick , because they have too many holes to full and they could more picks for the #1 over all pick then you for Manning. If Manning can back for at lease 3 years, you can get another QB and let him learn from one of the best to ever play the position.